Concerns About Aftermarket SMG II Pump Motors

If you own a BMW E46 M3 with SMG II, you already know how expensive the hydraulic pump can be. We want to address another product from a same German supplier — their replacement electric motor for the BMW E46 M3 SMG II hydraulic pump.

We’ve now seen several of these units in person, and there are some serious concerns.

What We’re Seeing

From what we’ve inspected and what customers have reported:

  • The motor appears to be an off-the-shelf, low-power unit normally used for windshield washer system that has been modified to fit.

  • Surfaces have been machined down to make it attach into the SMG pump housing.

  • The motor is smaller in capacity than the original unit.

  • It is fitted with a different bearing specification than what the system was designed for you will notice sleeve to accommodate this.

The SMG II system is not forgiving. The pump motor is engineered to operate under very specific load, pressure, and duty cycle conditions. When you reduce capacity or change bearing design, you’re introducing risk.

Why This Is a Problem

The SMG pump motor:

  • Must handle repeated high-pressure cycles

  • Needs correct torque output

  • Relies on proper bearing support under load

Using a lower-capacity motor with incorrect bearings can result in:

  • Overheating

  • Premature bearing failure

  • Reduced pump performance

  • Complete hydraulic system failure

And once again — when the pump fails, the repair bill goes up fast.

Our Position

We’re not against aftermarket solutions. But they must be:

  • Properly engineered for the application

  • Built to OEM-level tolerances

  • Tested under real operating conditions

  • Don’t assume “German-made” automatically means OEM-level quality.

Taking a generic motor and machining it to “make it fit” is not the same thing as designing a motor specifically for the SMG II system.

If you’re considering replacing your SMG pump motor, make sure you understand exactly what you’re installing — and whether it was truly engineered for the job.

Back to News